In most cases, no repairs are legally mandatory after a home inspection. A home inspection isn’t a pass/fail test, and no law makes a seller fix what the report finds. A repair becomes required in four ways: your lender demands it, state law sets a rule, your town’s code applies, or your purchase contract says so.
In southern New Hampshire and Vermont, that list often touches radon, well water, septic systems, and lead paint in older homes. At Norway Hill Home Inspections, we see these issues on reports all across the region. Below, we cover each source of a “must-fix,” what NH and VT rules say, and how to sort your own report.
Are Any Repairs Required by Law After a Home Inspection?
No federal or state law forces a seller to make repairs just because an inspector found a problem. Your inspection report is advice for you, the buyer. What happens next is a negotiation.
A fix only becomes “mandatory” when one of these four things applies:
- Your lender. FHA, VA, and USDA loans have minimum property standards. A conventional loan can also be approved “subject to” repairs the appraiser flags.
- State law. New Hampshire has a septic rule for some waterfront homes. Both states have disclosure rules.
- Local code. Your town may require permits, smoke detectors, or a hookup to town water or sewer.
- Your contract. If you and the seller sign a repair addendum, those repairs become part of the deal.
Keep one thing straight: a required disclosure is not a required repair. New Hampshire law (RSA 477:4-a) makes sellers give buyers written notice about radon, arsenic in well water, and lead paint. The same law says the seller does not have to test for or fix any of them. Federal lead rules work the same way.
So the real question is not “what does the law say the seller must fix?” It’s “what will stop my loan, break a rule, or put my family at risk?”
Lender-Required Repairs: FHA, VA, USDA, and Conventional Loans
Your loan type is the most common reason a repair turns mandatory. The lender’s appraiser, not your home inspector, decides what has to be fixed before the loan can close.
If the appraisal comes back “subject to” repairs, those repairs must be done (or escrowed, when the lender allows it) before closing.
|
Loan type |
Standard the home must meet |
Repairs that often come up |
|---|---|---|
|
FHA |
HUD minimum property standards: safe, sound, and secure |
Peeling or chipping paint in pre-1978 homes, active roof leaks, exposed wiring, missing handrails, broken heat, utilities not working |
|
VA minimum property requirements: safe, structurally sound, and sanitary |
Roof and structure problems, unsafe electrical, no working heat, pest damage, water and sewer problems |
|
|
USDA Rural Development |
Water and waste systems must be adequate and safe |
Well or septic problems (testing when the lender, appraiser, or inspector calls for it), chipping lead-based paint |
|
Conventional |
Appraiser’s judgment and lender guidelines |
Safety or structural items the appraiser marks “subject to” |
A few details matter for buyers here:
- FHA and pre-1978 paint. If the home was built before 1978, cracked or peeling paint usually has to be fixed before an FHA loan closes. That’s common in the older farmhouses and capes around Keene, Peterborough, and Brattleboro.
- Wells and septic. FHA and USDA don’t always require a well or septic test. They do when local rules call for one, when the appraiser suspects a problem, or when it’s standard practice in the area. Many lenders in rural NH and VT ask for a water test, so plan for it.
- Rules change. HUD has been working on updates to its property standards. Always confirm the current list with your loan officer.
Who pays for lender-required repairs is up to you and the seller. Often the seller makes the fix. Sometimes the price drops or the buyer covers the cost. That part is negotiable. The repair itself is not, if you want the loan.
NH and VT Rules That Can Make a Fix Mandatory
Northern New England homes come with their own set of issues. Most of them are about what’s in the ground and the water, not just what’s in the walls.
Radon in Air and Water
The EPA recommends fixing your home if radon is 4 pCi/L or higher, and suggests you consider fixing it between 2 and 4 pCi/L. Granite bedrock makes high radon common in both states.
- New Hampshire: Sellers must give the radon notice in RSA 477:4-a. Testing and mitigation are not required by law.
- Vermont: There’s no state law requiring radon disclosure at sale.
So radon is rarely “mandatory” in the legal sense. But a high result is a health issue, and it’s one of the most common items buyers ask sellers to fix. That’s why most NH and VT buyers should test for radon even when no law requires it.
A radon test during your inspection tells you where you stand before your contingency deadline. If the number comes back high, a mitigation system is a fairly routine fix. Even if you’re buying a house that already has a radon mitigation system, a fresh test confirms it still works. Radon can also show up in deep well water, which leads to the next topic.
Private Well Water
Neither state requires a well test before every home sale. But a private well is your only water source, and some lenders require a passing test.
- New Hampshire: Under RSA 477:4-c, sellers must disclose the well type, location, age, known problems, and the date and results of the last water test. NH Department of Environmental Services suggests buyers order their own home buyer well test. That test checks for arsenic, bacteria, chloride, copper, fluoride, hardness, iron, lead, manganese, nitrate and nitrite, pH, radon, sodium, and uranium. NHDES also suggests testing at least once for VOCs and PFAS.
- Vermont: Testing isn’t required at sale, but the Vermont Department of Health urges buyers to test, and sellers with private wells should hand over the state’s well testing guide for home buyers.
If a test shows high arsenic or bacteria, treatment becomes a must-fix for many lenders and for your own health. Finding that out before closing is the whole point of well water testing for home buyers, which covers the full NH home buyer panel.
Septic Systems
Septic is where New Hampshire has a true mandatory rule.
Under RSA 485-A:39 (updated September 1, 2024), if any part of the septic system sits within 250 feet of the shoreland reference line of protected waters, a licensed septic system evaluator must assess it before the sale. The buyer hires the evaluator.
A seller’s evaluation done in the past 180 days can be accepted in writing. If the system has failed, the sale can still close, but the system must be replaced within 180 days, with a possible extension. The NH waterfront septic statute spells out the full timeline.
Away from the water, NH sellers still have to disclose septic size, type, age, location, last pumping date, and known problems. Vermont generally doesn’t require a septic inspection at sale, but permit records matter.
Even when no law applies, a failing leach field can cost tens of thousands of dollars. A septic evaluation before closing checks the tank and leach field so the bill doesn’t land on you after you move in. If you’ve never had one done, here’s what a septic inspection involves from start to finish.
Lead Paint in Pre-1978 Homes
Federal law covers every home built before 1978. The seller must give you the EPA lead pamphlet, a signed lead disclosure form, and any lead records they have. You also get 10 days to test for lead before you’re locked in, unless you agree in writing to a different period or waive it.
The seller does not have to remove lead paint under this rule. Lead becomes a must-fix when an FHA, VA, or USDA appraiser flags chipping or peeling paint. Not sure if your home is old enough to matter? It helps to know when lead paint stopped being used in homes. If the house was built before 1978, a lead inspection during your 10-day window shows what’s there before you’re locked in.
Safety and Structural Defects You Should Treat as Must-Fix
Some problems aren’t required by any law, but you should still treat them as non-negotiable.
These are the items that hurt people or cost the most later:
- Structural problems: foundation cracks with movement, sagging beams, rotted sills
- Roof leaks: active water intrusion, failing flashing, ice dam damage
- Electrical hazards: exposed or scorched wiring, double-tapped breakers, missing GFCI outlets near water, old fuse panels with oversized fuses
- Heating and gas problems: cracked heat exchangers, backdrafting chimneys, gas leaks, carbon monoxide risk
- Water and mold: wet basements, plumbing leaks, active mold growth
- Wood-destroying insects: carpenter ants, termites, and powderpost beetle damage
- Missing smoke and CO detectors: often required by local code and cheap to fix
Lenders often flag the same list. Even with a cash purchase, these belong at the top of your repair request.
What Isn’t Mandatory: Cosmetic Issues and Normal Wear
Most of a typical report is not a must-fix. These items rarely belong in a repair request:
- Scuffed floors, worn carpet, and old paint (in homes built after 1978)
- Minor caulking, loose cabinet doors, and small drywall cracks
- An older water heater or furnace that still works safely
- Dated kitchens and bathrooms
Asking for every small item is one of the most common home inspection negotiation mistakes, and it can sour the deal. Save your negotiating capital for the things that matter.
How to Sort Your Inspection Report: Must-Fix, Negotiate, or Let Go
Sorting your report into three groups makes your next step clear.
|
Category |
What goes here |
Typical NH and VT examples |
|---|---|---|
|
Must-fix |
Lender-required, legally required, or serious safety issues |
FHA peeling paint, failed waterfront septic, exposed wiring, active roof leak |
|
Negotiate |
Costly items that affect value or health |
High radon, arsenic in well water, aging septic, old roof near end of life |
|
Let go |
Cosmetic or minor maintenance |
Worn floors, small cracks, dripping faucet |
For each must-fix or negotiate item, the seller usually has three options:
- Repair it before closing, ideally with a licensed contractor and receipts
- Give a credit at closing so you can fix it yourself
- Lower the price to reflect the cost
If the seller refuses a must-fix item, your inspection contingency may let you walk away. Talk with your agent about the timeline in your contract. Once repairs are done, ask for invoices and permits, and check the work at your final walkthrough.
Related Questions to Explore
Who pays for repairs after a home inspection?
There’s no set rule. The buyer and seller negotiate it. Sellers often pay for lender-required repairs to keep the sale on track, but a credit or price cut is just as common. If you’re not sure how to start that conversation, it helps to know what happens after a home inspection, from reading the report to sending a repair request.
Is the seller required to make FHA repairs?
No. The seller isn’t legally required to make them. But if the FHA appraisal lists required repairs, the loan won’t close until they’re done. So if the seller says no, the buyer may need to pay, switch loans, or walk away.
Can the buyer pay for FHA-required repairs?
Often, yes. The repairs must be finished and approved by the lender before closing. Because the buyer doesn’t own the home yet, the seller has to agree to let the work happen. Ask your lender how they handle it.
Does FHA require peeling paint to be repaired?
In homes built before 1978, yes, in most cases. Peeling, chipping, or cracked paint is treated as a possible lead hazard and must be fixed before an FHA loan closes.
What should you do after you receive the inspection report?
Read the full report and flag any safety, structural, or lender-required items first. Get quotes for the big ones, then decide with your agent whether to ask the seller for repairs, a credit, or a lower price. Keep an eye on your contract deadlines, since your window to respond is limited.
Does a conventional loan require a home inspection?
No. A conventional loan requires an appraisal, not an inspection. The appraiser can still require repairs for safety or structural problems. A home inspection is your own protection, and it’s well worth it.
When to Call a Professional
Call a licensed home inspector before you sign anything final, and again any time you’re unsure whether a problem is a must-fix.
Bring in a pro when:
- Your lender is FHA, VA, or USDA and you want to spot required repairs before the appraiser does
- The home has a private well or septic system
- The home was built before 1978
- The property sits near a lake, pond, or river in New Hampshire
- The report mentions structure, roof, electrical, or water problems you can’t judge on your own
Kurtis “Kurt” Grassett, CMI, and our team are licensed home inspectors in New Hampshire and Vermont with septic evaluation licensing. We test for radon, water quality, and lead in one visit, so you aren’t juggling vendors. Every report comes with our free Repair Roadmap, which sorts safety concerns from routine maintenance.
We serve towns from Keene, Peterborough, and Concord to Brattleboro, Hanover, and Woodstock, and we back our work with a 200% Satisfaction Guarantee.
Conclusion
Most inspection findings are up for negotiation, not required by law. The fixes that become mandatory come from your lender, NH or VT rules, your town, or your contract.
- Lender rules (FHA, VA, USDA, and “subject to” appraisals) are the biggest source of required repairs.
- NH waterfront septic is a true legal requirement. Radon, well water, and lead mostly trigger disclosures, not repairs.
- Safety and structural defects should be treated as must-fix, no matter the loan.
Buying in southern New Hampshire or Vermont? Schedule your home buyer inspection with Kurt and the team, or call us to get on the schedule.


